During a May 4 interview on NBC’s Meet the Press, Donald Trump was asked by moderator Kristen Welker whether he believed he was required to follow constitutional principles, especially in the context of his administration’s plans for mass deportation. His reply: “I don’t know. I’m not a lawyer. I don’t know.” This wasn’t an isolated moment of evasion. When asked again if he needed to uphold the Constitution, Trump deflected: “I have brilliant lawyers that work for me… they are going to obviously follow what the Supreme Court said.” The president of the United States, sworn to preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution, could not affirm that he even needs to obey it.
“I don’t know.” Three words that should chill anyone paying attention. Three words that make it unmistakably clear—Donald Trump is no longer capable of understanding the office he occupies, let alone executing its obligations.
This isn’t a legal argument. It’s not a philosophical dispute over constitutional interpretation. It’s a confession of incapacity. Because no president, regardless of ideology, history, or party, can do that job while disclaiming the duty to uphold the founding document of the republic.
The White House continues to insist he is in “excellent health.” His latest physical exam, conducted in April by White House physician Captain Sean Barbabella, portrayed a man in peak form. Weight: 224 pounds. Blood pressure: slightly elevated. Cholesterol: optimal. Cognitive function: perfect. “Fit to execute the duties of the Commander-in-Chief.” But the words now ring hollow. Because fitness is more than a checklist. And cognitive assessments like the Montreal Cognitive Assessment, are not proof of capacity. They’re baseline screeners. A person with early dementia can pass them. A person with severe personality disorders can ace them. They measure neither insight nor judgment.
Outside the carefully crafted medical statements, the reality has been harder to contain. Mental health professionals—those not bound by political loyalty or institutional censorship—have issued increasingly urgent warnings. Dr. John Gartner, a clinical psychologist who taught at Johns Hopkins, has declared Trump shows unmistakable signs of dementia. Deterioration in verbal fluency. Short-term memory lapses. Disorganized speech. Episodes of confusion. Motor dysfunction. Physical rigidity. Observable signs of frontal-lobe dysfunction. The president’s speech has grown increasingly jumbled. His syntax has degraded. He repeats himself. He loses track of thoughts. He mangles names. He insists, repeatedly, that he is running against Barack Obama. And no one in his inner circle corrects him.
There are over 3,000 clinicians aligned with Gartner’s “Duty to Warn” movement. Many have stated unequivocally that the president is showing clear clinical evidence of cognitive decline. Dr. Bandy Lee, editor of The Dangerous Case of Donald Trump, has called it a national emergency. Their concern is not political. It is neurological. And when the president of the United States is asked, on live television, whether he is required to follow the Constitution and answers “I don’t know,” their diagnosis gains weight. Because that is not a political gaffe. That is a breakdown in the executive function required to uphold democratic office.
The dissonance between official medical reports and public behavior has precedent. Reagan’s cognitive decline was whispered about for years before it was officially acknowledged. Woodrow Wilson’s stroke was concealed from the public entirely. Presidential health has long been subject to secrecy, distortion, and outright deception. But Trump’s case is different in one key way: the breakdown is not hidden. It is broadcast in real time, and the response from the White House is not silence—it’s denial.
The physical signs are clear. Trump’s gait has shifted. His posture has stiffened. His movement has become slower, more deliberate, more cautious. He slurs certain consonants. He speaks with a halting cadence. And yet, the president is presented to the public as fit, sharp, vigorous. This contradiction—between what the public sees and what the White House says—is unsustainable. It insults the intelligence of the electorate. It undermines institutional credibility. And it places the country in real danger.
There is no constitutional requirement that a president pass a specific medical exam. The 25th Amendment allows for the removal of a president who is “unable to discharge the powers and duties of his office,” but the mechanisms depend on political actors. The Cabinet. The Vice President. Congress. All of whom, in Trump’s case, have strong incentives to look the other way. Which leaves the American public watching a man unravel while being told he’s perfectly fine.
The presidency is not ceremonial. It requires the ability to read intelligence briefings, command military strategy, navigate diplomatic crises, interpret constitutional law, and respond to emergencies. A president who does not understand his obligation to uphold the Constitution cannot fulfill any of these roles.
The United States is being governed by a man who treats due process as optional, constitutional duties as legal trivia, and the rule of law as a nuisance. Whether this stems from apathy, authoritarianism, or genuine cognitive decline is increasingly irrelevant. The result is the same. The country is being led by someone who no longer recognizes the responsibilities of the role—and may no longer understand them at all.
The danger now is twofold. First, that Trump’s degeneration continues unchecked, protected by a wall of sycophancy and denial. Second, that his authoritarian instincts, unmoored from legal or constitutional limits, escalate into actions that do lasting damage to democratic institutions. The president’s open disdain for constitutional protections, his fixation on loyalty over law, and his increasingly erratic communication all point to a deeper unraveling.
No physical exam can explain away a refusal to affirm the basic duties of the presidency. No cognitive test can offset the erosion of judgment and comprehension now visible to anyone paying attention. The issue is no longer hypothetical. It is happening now.
The man with the nuclear codes just said he doesn’t know if he’s supposed to follow the Constitution.
The Index is a reader-supported, indie publication.
Now, more than ever, the world needs an independent press that is unencumbered by commercial conflicts and undue influence.
By taking out an optional founding membership, you can help us build a free, accessible, independent news platform firewalled from corporate interests.
